Last year Roberta read in manuscript my recently published book of short stories "All They Had, " remebrances of World War II with an eye to glaring errors, style, grammar, and general literary content and pointed out several glaring errors and omissions for which I will be eternally grateful. Her eye is sharp and her knowledge of language impressive. But then she can also write and write well herself so it is small wonder. But it is a wonder. I recommend and commend her to all.